Jan 5, 2017. smallhorses. May 6, 2010 #3 Jim Butcher's wizards do magic by imagining a thing and making said thing real by pouring magic energy into it with their will. Elminster vs. Mordenkainen. And in keeping with the mage vs. mage theme, Raistlin vs. Elminster and a few Black Mage fights. She taught him of the Weave, the invisible threads that make magic possible in the Forgotten Realms. Nov 19, 2020 #20 Nobody knows what he's capable of except in a few brief moments when he starts casting his crazy spells to jam doorways, set the forest ablaze with eldritch fire, duel the balrog, etc. Mystra was eventually reincarnated through a wizard named Midnight, restoring Elminster's power. He set up shop in some small town to 'plug the cork' vs a Dark Threat To All The Realms. Reply. Serious. Okay, it's the battle you all waited for: Elminster of Shadowdale vs Raistlin Majere.We use the D20/D&D 3E versions of them. Forgotten Realms is a campaign setting for the Dungeons & Dragons fantasy role-playing game. Next Last. save hide report. Belit vs Red Sonja (Oh, my)? Gandalf wins, definitively! Forgotten Realms is a campaign setting for the Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) fantasy role-playing game.Commonly referred to by players and game designers alike as "The Realms", it was created by game designer Ed Greenwood around 1967 as a setting for his childhood stories. Pick your winners! Each character is at the height of their power. Wondering what it was about it that bothered him. Yoda vs. Gandalf vs. Dumbledore vs. Brom from eragon This topic is locked from further discussion. May 6, 2010 #2 Yyrkoon would be near the top I think. Elminster continues to be active in the 1490s, the era currently explored in D&D’s Fifth Edition, helping Toril recover from the ravages of the Spellplague and fending off the evil that would harm the world he calls home. KEEP READING: Baldur's Gate 3 Demo Teases a Triumphant Return, Ari David is pretty amazing. Now, groups can certainly choose to play those exact characters if they want but that is generally not the case. RELATED: Dungeons & Dragons Does Greek Mythology In Magic: The Gathering Theros Crossover. John Constantine vs. Dr. Stephen Strange vs. Elminster vs. Gandalf vs. Dumbledor vs. Merlin vs. Medivh. IAmTheMeat. He trained some of the great and famous wizards of yore - the Seven Sisters, the mad necromancer who founded The Cult of the Dragon, Khelben Blackstaff (well, maybe not him). elminster Member, Developer Posts: 16,186. This thread is archived. Elminster escaped with his life, taking his grandfather’s broken sword as his only keepsake from home. Merlin is from original Arthurian legend not Marvel. May 6, 2010 #2 Yyrkoon would be near the top I think. Gandalf is one of the main characters in The Hobbit and The Lord of The Rings respectfully. 317 Votes. He trained some of the great and famous wizards of yore - the Seven Sisters, the mad necromancer who founded The Cult of the Dragon, Khelben Blackstaff (well, maybe not him). If you like our work, please support us. Sidekick: The Chosen of Mystra, a.k.a. Who would emerge the victor if these two legendary mages fought it out? Any of the three could also be beaten on any given day. Originally called Olórin, he was accounted as the wisest of the Maiar (with the possible exception of Melian). In 1479 DR, he set out to find a cure for his love. Any of the three could win on any given day. ... Elminster vs Rincewind (Score: 4, Insightful) by javajawa on Tuesday December 21, 2004 @02:54PM Homepage. No way. +1 for Elminster. Alternatively, we imagine the learned, book bound, intelligent mastermind who always has a spell to help or hinder in any situation. I'm going to start with a literary, rather than a fanboy ("Do you think the Thing could beat the Hulk?") He was present when a potent magical ward called the mythal was raised, transforming the city of Cormanthor into the Elven stronghold of Myth Dranor. Ever intend to finish up Link vs Simon Belmont? Second of all, Merlin hangs around dreamboats like Lancelot (purr!) For several ages now, two sages have graced the halls of the Inter-Dimensional Retirement Community located on the estates of the Khazan Wizards Guild. Be they Gandalf, Elminster, Skywalker, Valen, Superman etc etc etc. Mar 29, 2015. My bet is on Rand vs. Aslan...Savior vs. Savior...ha ha. Over the next thousand years, Elminster was involved in many of the world-changing events that occurred on Toril. There any doubt? THE SCENARIO . He was taught many lessons, including Mystra turning him into a woman in order to gain a greater understanding of the world and a stronger connection to the Weave. Ever intend to finish up Link vs Simon Belmont? Related: 10 Tricks That'll Help You Playing D&D For the First Time. On the understanding of hard vs soft magic, it depends. 6 comments. Fascinated with the manifestation, Gandalf reaches down to touch the surface of the pool. That's a rough breakdown of the advantages each mage has in the conflict. Elminster Aumar (Dungeons & Dragons) Hellboy; History . Yet his ways often took him to Nienna, fro… It was originally created by author and game designer Ed Greenwood as a setting for his own stories, but after he discovered D&D he adapted it to the game system. BOBBY: My name is Robert De Loungville. Since its inception, Dungeons & Dragons has prominently featured wizards and the powerful magic they weave. Antvasima (talk) 08:55, October 31, 2018 (UTC) This seems like such a traditional arch-type in D&D, that I'm surprised this hasn't already been done. Lionelion Member since: Jun. Solamnic Knights vs. Knights of the Holy Grail, Scions (of DragonLance) vs. Scions (of Shannara), Queen of Darkness vs. Crown Prince of Darkness, Blister Vera Jay Nimblefingers vs. Olive Rustkettle, Blister Vera Jay Nimblefingers vs. Paxina Thistleknot, Billee Belladonna Juniper vs. Gollum/Sméagol, Paxina Thistleknot vs. Billee Belladonna Juniper. Raistlin vs Elminster. He can be imperious, grave, and terrible, however, and furthermore is a consummate actor. Okay, it's the battle you all waited for: Elminster of Shadowdale vs Raistlin Majere.We use the D20/D&D 3E versions of them. Elminster VS Szass Tam This Rumble ended on 2003-01-25 00:00:00.0. Mar 29, 2015. R. Rallan My Hat Of d02. They meet in a pocket plane. But his enmity with the Zhentarim would have tragic consequences later on. approach to this. Elminster's patron died, and he's now essentially powerless. Then his reflection blinked! Information. Post by Andragohn » Fri Oct 22, 2010 1:34 pm. Marvel's Venom Event Concludes, Elektra is Daredevil and Aliens Arrive in March 2021, Dungeons & Dragons' Greatest Wizard Is More Than a Gandalf Rip-Off, Dungeons & Dragons: Exploring Chult, the Dinosaur-Filled Jungle, Dungeons & Dragons Does Greek Mythology In Magic: The Gathering Theros Crossover, 10 Tricks That'll Help You Playing D&D For the First Time, Baldur's Gate 3 Demo Teases a Triumphant Return, Sonic 2: Knuckles’ Role in the Sequel Reportedly Leaks, Magic: The Gathering - Drafting a Commander Legends Deck for Brago, King Eternal, The 10 Best Multiplayer Switch Games (Updated 2020), Patty Jenkins Has One Major Requirement to Film Wonder Woman 3, Spider-Man: Miles Morales May Have Given Insomniac the Key to the Spider-Verse, Junji Ito's Remina Is a Modern Horror Classic - That We Don't Need Right Now, Good Omens Fans Will Enjoy Eniale & Dewiela Vol. Created by author and Forgotten Realms designer Ed Greenwood, Elminster was introduced in 1985. I think it was agreed upon in DnD revisions that the wish spell is causality manipulation ZacharyGrossman273 (talk) 22:10, October 30, 2018 (UTC) You can talk with some of the participants about it via their message walls. Gandalf from The Hobbit/Lord of the Rings vs Elminster from Dungeons & Dragon's Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting (if Deadliest Warrior did this, it be live action no doubt). Click the button below to start this article in quick view. And this picture alone is legitimate proof that Elminster is indeed Gandalf's Ultimate Imitator, something more people need to come to realize. Elminster is (maybe was) a Chosen of Mystra.He is magically old old old. and Galahad (spank me! "Doppelganger!" By naming a particular being or kind of being as you cast the spell, you cause the gate to open in the immediate vicinity of the desired creature and pull the subject through, willing or unwilling. He's a shapeshifter, and may be prophetic. Dungeons & Dragons has helped launch a number of fantasy writers including Ed Greenwood under the Forgotten Realms landscape. 6 comments. Knights of Neraka vs. Knights who say Ni. He rarely reveals the full extent of his true nature to anyone who is not an extremely close friend. Validated User. Reply. P. PrinceYyrkoon Retired User. Tomorrow will be the right side, etc. Battle for magical supremacy on modern day earth. I'm also completely ignoring TV and movies, and sticking to written sources. Pick your winners! Gandalf didnt make the horses appear from the river water. 13 years ago. They are a fan-favorite class that allow players to enjoy the fantasy of being an all-knowing, fireball hurling, master of the arcane, but on Toril, the world of the popular Forgotten Realms setting, there is no wizard more legendary than Elminster Aumar, the Sage of Shadowdale. Submit Templates; Contact Us; FAQ; Legal & Policies Eventually, he was rescued by a Chosen of Mystra named Simbul, and the two developed a relationship. Serious. Strictly by your votes. Gandalf the Grey is a wizard character from a fantasy novel Hobbit written in 1937 by J.R.R.Tolkein, an English professor of Oxford University. Quote; Link to post Share on other sites. Thank you! Myrjala revealed herself to have been Mystra in disguise all along, there to test him. But every day I will advance one side. Sorvan76 Member Posts: 76. Tomorrow will be the right side, etc. The Sidekick UA Spellcaster is somebody that studied under Gandalf/Elminster/Insert whatever higher tier variant which would be represented by its ability to reach up to 9th level spells. Raistlin Majere vs Elminster. However, his body was destroyed by Manshoon, the leader of his old foes, the Zhentarim. Gandalf’s initial appearance is as a wizard, but later on Gandalf appears as the chief of the Istari order after Saruman’s fall. Elminster Aumar. Over 1,200 years old as of Fifth Edition, Elminster has experienced his share of victories and tragedies across more lifetimes than most beings could understand. Impressed by Elminster, she asked him to be one of her Chosen -- an immortal being imbued with incredible power over the Weave. Now Elminster again, he sought to return to his home to free it of the magelords. He eventually resorted to burglary and was caught robbing the home of Stonecloak, a powerful spellcaster. Site Rules & Help : RPG Crossing > Discussions ... And in keeping with the mage vs. mage theme, Raistlin vs. Elminster and a few Black Mage fights. 29, 2009 Each of them has access to his signature items (for Raistlin, this means: The Staff of Magius, the Dragon Orb and the … 264 Votes, Gandalf He fits the same mold as Dumbledore or Obi-Wan Kenobi -- burdened with wisdom and responsibility, yet charming, and possessing a surprisingly good sense of humor. He set up shop in some small town to 'plug the cork' vs a Dark Threat To All The Realms. Puffs of smoke rings chased one another above his head forming a chain before dissipating. Mystra's Chosen > All. He tried to survive as a bandit and cutthroat, but found himself disliking the notion of killing. We have got Gandalf the Grey and Gandalf the White for the Ainu Olórin both with and without Narya. Gandalf or Saruman are two examples that we often see within the game. So prepare your forbidden books and steadily growing beards, magic fans, as we at Screen Rant ask Dumbledore Vs. Gandalf: Who's the Better Wizard? Strictly by your votes. Name: Elminster Favorite Spell: Seduce Mystra Arch-Enemy: I'm too powerful to have enemies. May 6, 2010 #4 The annoying "comedy … But having developed an intense hatred of magic as a result of his parent’s murder, he refused. 1 of 2 Go to page. He can portray himself as a trickster, a ra… 3781. More importantly, they should do some Forgotten Realms movies one day. Donate. Venage237's wall > Ever intend to finish up Link vs Simon Belmont? The rich text editor does not work with JavaScript switched off. Forgotten Realms is a campaign setting for the Dungeons & Dragons fantasy role-playing game. He writes and writes about Film, TV, Comics, and Games from his lair in Brooklyn. Gandalf leaned heavily on his staff staring into the magical reflecting pool. Copying the relevant mechanics of gate from the 3.5 SRD: "The second effect of the gate spell is to call an extraplanar creature to your aid (a calling effect). _____ Where there is a great deal of free speech, there is always a certain amount of foolish speech. For at lease one simple reason - Dumbledore, powerful as he was, still share the same weakness literally ALL Harry Potter universe characters have: They relies on their wands too much - even Voldemort. When Mystra was killed for trying to return to the heavens, it left Elminster powerless for a time. Elminster vs Rincewind (Score: 4, Insightful) by javajawa ( 126489 ) writes: on Tuesday December 21, 2004 @02:54PM ( #11151043 ) Homepage I think it is a tossup between Elminster … September 2014 in Off-Topic. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Reply. Elminster Elminster Aumar is a fictional character in the Forgotten Realms campaign setting for the Dungeons & Dragons fantasy role-playing game, also known as … OptimusPrime Member; 4273 posts; Share; Posted March 9, 2010. It’s really a tough question since there are so many “versions” of them. My friends call me Bobby. share. Gandalf is an archangel, but that doesn't mean much. Nobody knows what he's capable of except in a few brief moments when he starts casting his crazy spells to jam doorways, set the forest ablaze with eldritch fire, duel the balrog, etc. This Rumble ended on 2003-02-15 00:00:00.0. The rich text editor does not work with JavaScript switched off. You call me sir. Reply. Elminster Aumar battles fiends in the Nine Hells, by Matthew Stawicki. Ma'at - Goddess of Truth & Justice . Intentionally drawing inspiration from mythical and literary figures like Odin, Merlin and Gandalf, Elminster is the Forgotten Realms’ gray-bearded, pointy hat wearing, pipe-smoking, immortal sage. Goose and Lord of Legend. Usually, wizards are pretty old. In his \"youth\", he became one of the Maiar who served Manwë, Varda, Irmo and Nienna named. For nearly a hundred years, Elminster lived like this, growing bitter. Despite Elthryn’s desire to remain uninvolved, he and his wife Amrythale were slain by the evil mage lord, Undarl. Bobby De Loungville versus Gareth Bryne. 1, Second Coming: Only Begotten Son #1 Reveals Sunstar's Origins, King in Black: Immortal Hulk #1 Rings in a Silent Night, Black Cat Jumps Into a Solid Relaunch Against the King in Black, Dark Multiverse: Crisis on Infinite Earths Gives the Justice Society a Violent Epic, CBR Editor Picks: The Best Comics of 2020, The Mandalorian's Rebel Cameo May Reveal Who Saved Grogu From Order 66, Beyond Good and Evil 2: Everything We Know About the Game's Development So Far, Doctor Doom Confirms Marvel's Most POWERFUL Weapon Is NOT the Infinity Gauntlet, Dungeons & Dragons: Every New Tasha’s Cauldron of Everything Subclass, Ranked, A Classic Star Wars Game Still Exists on the Fringe of Canon, Darth Vader's Role in the Obi-Wan Series Could Fill a Return of the Jedi Plot Hole, What Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity's Ending Could Mean for Breath of the Wild 2, Magic: The Gathering - Building a Commander Deck for Jodah, Archmage Eternal, Marvel Studios Announces New Year's Eve Musical Event, Clubhouse Games is Nintendo's Overlooked 2020 Gem, The 5 Best Professional Wrestlers in Video Games. Battle for magical supremacy on modern day earth. In looks, sure. Like Gandalf in LotR. In looks, sure. In the early hours of Hammer 1, 1372 DR, Elminster entered the portal and narrowly managed to close it, but at the expense of much of his magical strength. Sidekick: The Chosen of Mystra, a.k.a. To be honest, the two don't really compare, because although they're both D&D settings, they're both very different. share. In 1372 DR, he sealed himself behind a portal to the Nine Hells so he could prevent hordes of devils from entering Toril and wreaking havoc. I'm curious how Voldemort would hold up against Gandalf or other very powerful wizards of other series. They meet in a pocket plane. Elminster looks in confusion at the man before him. Artist-Azar. In a flash of brilliant light the phantasm of the mirror appears in front of … Elminster is (maybe was) a Chosen of Mystra.He is magically old old old. Long time D&D fans may remember the Elminster series and what he was like as a wizard. Pug vs Harry Potter Merlin vs Kvothe Fizban vs Mazrim Taim Macros vs Gandolf Feel free to describe how the battle would take place. The Sidekick UA Spellcaster is somebody that studied under Gandalf/Elminster/Insert whatever higher tier variant which would be represented by its ability to reach up to 9th level spells. In a flash of brilliant light the phantasm of the mirror appears in front of him. And Elminster has ludicrously high levels. Mario and Sonic, Alien and Predator, Terminator and Robocop, Batman and Superman, Picard and Kirk, Elminster and Raistlin, Darth Vader and Seven of Nine, Gandalf and Merlin, Bahamut and Tiamat, Splinter and Shredder, Bond and Phelps, Trebek and Sajak, McGwire and Sosa, Shaq and Jordan, Kerrigan and Harding, Leno and Letterman, Cronkite and Brokaw, and Windows and Macintosh. Elminster, the Sage of Shadowdale, is a legendary figure in the lore of Dungeons & Dragons, and he's much more than a simple copy of Gandalf. The Weave collapsed, and Elminster lost many of his abilities as a Chosen of Mystra. If I'm the only one who votes, then so be it! Obviously some foul magic was at hand. I never paid much attention to Dragonlance (please keep the insults and demands for my being burned at a stake to a minimum), but Raistlin seemed pretty wimpy physically, too. Elminster was swayed and began to worship the goddess under her tutelage. They are a fan-favorite class that allow players to enjoy the fantasy of being an all-knowing, fireball hurling, master of the arcane, but on … Validated User. Grandolf vs. Elminster would be more fitting (Elminster would win, of course). It is even rumored he had a hand in the founding of the city of Waterdeep, or at the very least creating its hierarchy of lords. Elminster Aumar (born in 212 DR) is a fictional character in the Dungeons & Dragons-based Forgotten Realms setting. Rand vs. Gandalf? However, Elminster's background is significantly different from that of Gandalf. They are the famed wizards Merlin and Gandalf. Fascinated with the manifestation, Gandalf reaches down to touch the surface of the pool. Izrador vs Gandalf? Eventually, he was shown the magic to alter his form by a wizard named Myrjala. Name: Elminster Favorite Spell: Seduce Mystra Arch-Enemy: I'm too powerful to have enemies. His father Elthryn was one of the seven sons of Uthgrael Aumar who had left the palace intrigues to settle in the nearby village of Heldon, where he served as its lord. And this picture alone is legitimate proof that Elminster is indeed Gandalf's Ultimate Imitator, something more people need to come to realize. You could argue that this is soft magic (and in some ways it is), but it has hard rules and has to obey physics. It was worse for Simbul who needed to feed off of magical items in order to stay sane. Elminster 204 Votes. She sent Halaster Blackcloack, the Mad Mage of Undermountain into the Nine Hells, but he was defeated. Gandalf the Grey, as he is known through most of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings trilogy, is the epitome of a wizened old wizard – possibly owing to Merlin’s influence and possibly influencing Elminster’s appearance as well. Pug vs Harry Potter Merlin vs Kvothe Fizban vs Mazrim Taim Macros vs Gandolf Feel free to describe how the battle would take place. Unbeknown to Elminster, the magister was an agent of Mystra, and she wanted the young man to become a wizard. Nov 23, 2014. Fate had other plans for Elminster, and after years of adventures, he found himself visited by the goddess, Mystra. Elminster Elminster Aumar is a fictional character in the Forgotten Realms campaign setting for the Dungeons & Dragons fantasy role-playing game, also known as … If I'm the only one who votes, then so be it! Raistlin vs Gandalf General Discussion. Gandalf the Grey Gandalf the Grey . Mystra explained that she was the living embodiment of the Weave, and she wished him to learn from her so he may protect it. RPG Crossing Home: Forums: Create An Account! That was Aerowin, Steven Tyler's daughter. Jun 18, 2015. cancertz. It was originally created by author and game designer Ed Greenwood as a setting for his own stories, but after he discovered D&D he adapted it to the game system. Elminster’s soul was preserved, but it took Simbul sacrificing her life and the last of her energy to restore Elminster’s physical form. P. PrinceYyrkoon Retired User. Elminster Gandalf has the most innate power of the three (Elminster got a lot of help from Mystra whenever the yogurt hit the fan). Reply. John Constantine vs. Dr. Stephen Strange vs. Elminster vs. Gandalf vs. Dumbledor vs. Merlin vs. Medivh. Name Something you've created: The need for a library devoted to cataloguing all the things I've created. 11-15-2010, 08:34 AM. He was tortured by devils and subjected to acts of utter brutality until Mystra was able to hear Elminster’s plight. the Legion of Mortal Godlings. His backstory and further adventures have been explored in a series of novels from creator Ed Greenwood, starting with Elminster: The Making of a Mage in 1994, and continuing to appear in 13 novels over the decades.